Despite a recent decision by the Des Moines City Council
to pass an anti-Patriot Act resolution, Iowa City councilors
do not plan to follow suit.
Iowa City Council members were swarmed with letters and
verbal petitions about one year ago requesting they pass
a resolution opposing the act. But the council rejected
the requests based on its limited jurisdiction. Instead,
councilors instructed city staff to send a letter to Congress
expressing their concern about the act, which was enacted
just six weeks after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11,
2001.
"We sent a letter to Congress that was signed by all
seven councilors," Mayor Ernie Lehman said Wednesday.
"That is probably the extent to which we will act."
The act gives law enforcement officials unprecedented
power to access information about suspected terrorists.
Among the many concerns residents have raised is the ease
with which authorities can gain citizens' records, including
those held by doctors, libraries, bookstores, universities
and Internet service providers.
Because officials with the Iowa City Public Library have
traditionally emphasized their efforts to keep all records
confidential, they began posting signs last fall warning
customers that the level of security was no longer as
high as it had been.
"Now these records are perhaps not as confidential as
people had assumed them to be," said Library Director
Susan Craig, adding that while staff has not yet reposted
the signs since opening the new and larger library, they
plan to. "As library director, I believe the provision
allowing government officials to look at library records
is wrong. I don't agree with it at all."
That doesn't mean she will urge the council toward a
resolution opposing the Patriot Act. She said that should
be a community-led effort.
"But as to how effective it is for the city to pass a
resolution, I'm ambiguous," Craig said.
Ben Stone, executive director of the Iowa Civil Liberties
Union, who lobbied the Des Moines City Council to pass
its resolution, said in a release Tuesday that the increasing
number of communities adopting anti-Patriot Act resolutions
helps "generate bi-partisan efforts in Congress to amend
portions of the Patriot Act."
According to Stone, since the Patriot Act was adopted
in 2001, four states and 338 cities have passed resolutions
of opposition representing more than 53 million people.
Only Ames and Des Moines have passed resolutions in Iowa.
"When you see Des Moines, which is not associated with
a partisan leaning on this issue, it empowers Republicans,"
Stone said. "Too many politicians need to see convincing
evidence that people will not retaliate against them if
they show leadership."
Stone said that since 2002, the number of cities passing
resolutions has more than doubled, a trend he expects
to continue.